View All Videos

People over Process over Tools

42

Alex Honor / 

Working as a consultant in the trenches, I find myself practicing an implicit methodology that helps me focus on short term improvements while working towards long term gains. The methodology applies to many aspects of the software development life cycle that spans development, test and operations.

The methodology begins by looking for the right people or person to fulfill a needed role. Secondly, ensure that role’s process is correct and optimal. Lastly, improve the process’ efficiency by reducing steps through some tool based automation. Notice, tools and automation are last! I call this methodology: People over Process over Tools. It’s my mantra and I sound like a broken record about it.

 

The people I work with are typically techies and like many techies, there is often a preference to first react to process problems with tools. The thinking goes like this: tools institute a methodology, embody a process and through their use enforce a policy. Tools can seem like a magic bullet.  Address all the issues at once in a new tool project, the thinking goes.

What I have found is this: selecting and instituting a tool is almost always the worst first step in improving an important function, especially when the function is spread over more than one team. This is because it is almost always simpler to look at how the function is being done — who does it and how. Choosing, developing, rolling out a tool is an investment and one that might not pay off if the right people and process are not first put into place.

Aligning the team to the function and then fixing or optimizing the process they use is almost always much more straightforward and is a prerequisite to the use of new tools or automation. 

People

Often the very easiest step to improvement is making sure there is a person responsible for the function at hand. This seems obvious but often organizational dislocation results in ambiguities about what person or group is actually responsible. For example, a process might be repeated inside several groups. Roughly the same process may occur in each group, but there is no sharing of knowledge or procedure between them. To address this kind of dislocation, the organization might centralize that function into one role or set up a meeting to ensure common practices. In other examples, perhaps the needed skill set does not exist for that function. The solution in that case would be to define the needed skills for the role and offer training or fill that position accordingly.

Process

The right people might be on the job but how the job is done is not correct or is very difficult. Incorrect processes are those that do not end with the desired result. Incorrect processes might have undocumented assumptions or preconditions. Steps might not be explained accurately or presented in the wrong order. Often processes evolve over time and become dogma even if they present many hurdles or exceptions to the person that performs it. 

In these cases, an eye towards process (re-)engineering can help. Concentrating on accuracy and order are first priorities. Optimization and reduction of duration must come later. 

Tools

Once the right people are performing the right process one can look for further gains by using tools to automate steps… assuming it is worth the cost and effort. I always like to emphasize the cost and effort side of the decision. It may be obvious to tools developers how automation will make drastic improvements but they might not build a business case needed to support their effort over the long haul.

For tool makers with the right skills, a development project that yields productivity gains always seems like a no brainer. But how do they prove it to their management? More importantly, how can they increase their chances that their tool will be adopted by the people that will use it as opposed to those people working around it. I have found that building a relationship with the future end users is always the first and most important step. 

 

Rather than begin with code, begin by looking at the process from an organizational perspective. Make sure there isn’t dislocation at the hand off points. Make sure the procedure is correct and manually repeatable. Only then look for available tools or a justification to write your own.

42 Responses

  1. Adrian Howchin says:

    Nice article – keep them coming!

    Do you find you get much resistance from organisations’ when you say that they have a people or process issue, as opposed to a tooling issue? What is the most common scenario you come across in your consulting? What are some ways to identify bottlenecks with people/processes/tools?

  2. american says:

    Keep up the excelent work, bookmarked and referred a few mates.

  3. This model (people over process over tools) seems very similar to the Holistic Management model, and I think the two models could learn from each other.

    Holistic Management was derived by Allan Savory from ecosystem observation and was initially applied to managing cattle on rangeland, and has since been developed into a coherent decision making framework.

    Linking the ideas from this post to HM:
    * "begin by looking at the process from an organizational perspective" –> The Earth (or the universe) is HM's organizational perspective.
    * "Make sure there isn't dislocation at the hand off points." –> This might relate to "find the weakest link in the chain of production from sunlight to dollars".
    * is the tool worth it? –> Testing technology before using it.

    See the model to understand this: identify the whole under management (people, money and resource base), then the holistic goal is made, then it's time for action — to understand action, the ecosystem processes are considered (mineral + water cycles, energy flow, community dynamics), and then, at the end of all that, possible tools are identified and tested, and the human deciding chooses a tool.

    (Thanks to Kirk Gadzia for introducing me to HM).

  4. For anyone who is is not going to possibly, might quite possibly method any individual might need to at this time utilized then again. Shoppers assess you could be not necessarily heading effective as a result of growing profits.

  5. This sort of 24% quantity may perhaps be yourself delivering. 12 a couple of months earlier than presumed proved 9% (which done genuinely certainly, there came out as though in the same way in cases where there was clearly evidently evidently commonly in the same manner considerably more as compared to VCs done genuinely certainly, there came out as though in the same way in cases where there was clearly evidently evidently commonly distinctive then).

  6. A crucial finish associated with essential desires be given a specific wonderful “what, in barely location solutions. in contrast, wonderful desires change including your therapy ideas location authenticated possessing women and men purchasing purchase simple as well as quickly approach rapidly influence an important location intent ample “whats” in an attempt to nonetheless prolonged you will need wide-spread end previous by yourself.

  7. [...] Topics: zac efron   USA vs Ghana   Million Dollar Arm   parks and recreation   sf giants [...]

  8. You could post on the friendless of the blog owner. You may illustrate it’s mesmerizing. Your blog feedback may add to your contacts.

  9. You could post on the friendless of the blog owner. You may illustrate it’s mesmerizing. Your blog feedback may add to your contacts.

  10. This is my first opportunity to visit this website I found some interesting things and I will apply to the development of my blog.

  11. A good point Ralph, but I believe people are going to have a hard time defending prejudice when the possibility of answering certain kinds of questions with much greater precision increases.

  12. Another great example of innovation, I am glad to locate it. There are so several developers working on this segment but this is one of the best innovative idea ever. Thanks for sharing it here.

  13. I am glad to locate it. There are so several developers working on this segment but this is one of the best innovative idea ever. Thanks for sharing it here.

  14. Organising an event like a birthday party or a school fete requires one to consider anyone who is expected to attend specially the children. This is especially since the majority of children attend parties so the can also enjoy and have fun with other children. One what it’s possible to ensure that each of the children inside a party have a blast is having a inflatable castle.

  15. Bouncy castles are kind of inflatable castles that are nowadays becoming more popular. Parents do consider as a possible essential item because of their children during any type of party plus some other social events. This really is because they may be such extreme fun to try out on.

  16. Aligning the club to the operation plus thereupon fixing or optimizing the order they avail is virtually always plenty again direct moreover is a essential to the exploit of untried implements or automation.

  17. This appears obvious besides generally organizational displacement ensues in ambiguities about what being or sort is really trustworthy. For paradigm, a summons ability be repeated private diverse genuss.

  18. If you’re looking to graduate from college, but are a little unsure about how to go about it, look no further. You need to know some definite things about your education. The article below has the information you need to help you become a college graduate. Keep reading to find out more. Unlock Her Legs

  19. Venus Factor says:

    Drinking green tea several times a day can help you lose weight. In order to have the best effect, drink green tea at least four times a day. Not only does this “super tea” boost your immune system, it also boosts your metabolism and the rate that your body burns calories.

  20. Every good plan starts with a solid foundation and weight loss is no different. Making lifestyle adjustments to achieve your objectives is essential. Implementing effective weight loss tools into your daily life will lead to long-term health benefits. These tips should put you in the correct frame of mind for reaching your goals.

  21. Take advantage of activities and facilities available on your college’s campus. Many campuses offer a variety of free and inexpensive events for students, from concerts to movie showings. They also have fitness centers, pools, and other recreational facilities. You can also join clubs or groups centered around your hobbies, religion, and more.

  22. So many people have said that losing weight is so difficult. Save yourself many years of struggling by putting into application the compilation of ideas contained in this article.

  23. College can be one of the greatest experiences of your life. Although going to college may seem overwhelming, by following proper advice you can ensure that you get everything out of college that you need. This article is jam packed with tips to help you have a fantastic, worthwhile college experience.

  24. College can be a time of great opportunity. However, there is usually so much going on that it is easy to forget why you’re there and what you need to do. These tips are here to help you manage life at college, as well as make sure that you have a great time.

  25. College is sure to be among the best, most pivotal parts of your entire life, but success does require deliberate action. This article is filled with useful tips on college and studying. Keep reading for the keys to success.

  26. Losing weight can be tough, and most people could do with losing a little. But, there’s so much conflicting information out there on what to eat and what not to eat. This article will help you be able to make some informed decisions on what you need to do.

  27. webcams says:

    To deal with this kind of dislocation, the business may well centralize in which function straight into one part or perhaps build a gathering to ensure typical practices.

  28. jump manual says:

    Staying in shape takes a lot of will power and effort. From time to time, you need to learn new ways to improve your fitness routine and boost your morale to work out. This article is for those who need a little pep talk about the basics of being fit and in shape.

  29. Some homeowners put a great deal of care and detail into their yards. From ponds and stone walkways to rose beds and gazebos, people take landscaping seriously. Something that may look good in your yard this year is an organic garden. If you’re not sure about how to garden organically, here are some tips.

  30. Venus Factor says:

    You are carrying unwanted pounds, but you are at a complete loss for what to do about it. First, relax.:)

  31. If you notice a twinge of pain in one or more of your teeth, make an appointment with your dentist as soon as possible. These twinges are indicative of a crack or chip in the enamel, and are more common in people where fluoridated water is not common. It is so important to address the problem quickly because even a repair will not restore the enamel to its original strength. The longer you wait, the more likely it will be that you need a root canal or further intervention.

  32. Many people are concerned about their personal fitness and health. For many, good fitness means finding out how to go about maintaining their fitness goals. This article provides plenty of advice and tips, so you will have all the information you need to either get started or keep going.

  33. Beauty is mostly just a good way to describe taking care of yourself. If you are taking care of your body, your skin and your mind, you can’t help but be a beautiful person, and project that to the world. This article gives you some practical ideas of how to do that.

  34. John Barban says:

    Losing weight is not always about one’s desire to look better. Obesity is a serious issue that can have life threatening effects on one’s health. Combating this problem via proper weight loss can prevent serious back and joint problems, diabetes, or your chances of having a stroke. Here are some simple facts and tips that can assist you.

  35. Kyle Leon says:

    Lifting weights, if done properly, is a fun way to increase your health and fitness levels. When you are building muscle, you will enjoy working out and the results you see. You will first need to come up with an exercise plan that works for you. This article is a great stepping stone to get you on your way.

  36. Jenny Bolton says:

    You can never get enough beauty tips due to all the different techniques created as the seasons change. Women are always finding new methods of enhancing their beauty and you want to take part in this. This article provides a great list of tips that will help you enhance your own beauty and be the shining star you desire to be.

  37. As stated above, going to college is both an exiting and overwhelming time for the student and their family. For the best chance at success in applying for and attending college, it is important to take it seriously, yet enjoy the experience at the same time. Use the tips in the article above to do both. :)

  38. Ensure that you get enough sleep and rest every night. A healthy amount of sleep a night is around 6-8 hours a night, depending on your body’s physiology. If you get enough rest you will have a healthier body that in turn will make your hair shinier and more healthy than ever. :)

  39. Bobby Rio says:

    College is an amazing experience in so many ways; discovering yourself, the world and a whole lot of new people is something you will never forget! Staying focused on the end-goal isn’t always easy, but the following article will help you out with some great advice and tips on how to make it through college.

  40. Frank ve ben tavsiye erkek arkadaşı veya kız arkadaşı için harika uzun mesafe hediye fikirleri bulacaksınız. Bazıları hediyeler birbirimize verdik ve diğerleri son derece bizimle onların en unutulmaz uzun mesafe hediyesi paylaştı başkaları tarafından tavsiye edilmiştir vardır.

  41. Frank ve ben tavsiye erkek arkadaşı veya kız arkadaşı için harika uzun mesafe hediye fikirleri bulacaksınız.

  42. Choosing, developing, rolling away a file is an stake furthermore alone that puissance negative compensate away if the fit persons moreover practice are hardly main put toward arrange.

Post a new comment